Skip to content
Columbus Coin BuyersCoins, gold and silver

Home / What we buy / Silver dollars

Selling silver dollars in Columbus

Morgan and Peace dollars, trade dollars and silver Eisenhowers. Sorted by date and mint and graded one at a time.

Row of Morgan silver dollars

Dollars we buy

  • Morgan dollars, 1878 to 1904 and 1921
  • Peace dollars, 1921 to 1935
  • Trade dollars
  • Seated Liberty dollars
  • Silver Eisenhower dollars
  • American Silver Eagles
  • Certified dollars

How silver dollars are priced

Morgan and Peace dollars are 90 percent silver and hold about 0.77 troy ounces each. A worn common date sells a bit over its silver.

Carson City dollars, scarce San Francisco and New Orleans dates and coins in high grades sell for much more. Each better dollar gets its own line on the offer.

Silver dollars in Columbus families

Silver dollars were a standard gift in Ohio families for births, confirmations and graduations, and many households ended up with a small stack in a drawer. Some families also kept a canvas bank bag of dollars as rainy-day money.

We count every dollar with you, sort them by date and mint and grade the ones that might carry a premium.

Morgan dates worth a closer look

Morgans came from Philadelphia, New Orleans, San Francisco, Carson City and, in 1921, Denver. Worn coins of the everyday dates bring roughly their silver value. These deserve real attention.

  • Any Carson City dollar
  • 1889-CC and 1893-S
  • 1895, known mostly as proofs
  • 1884-S and 1892-S in higher grades
  • Dollars with deep mirror fields or natural toning

Peace dollars

Peace dollars were struck from 1921 to 1935, with no coins dated 1929 through 1933. The 1921 high relief coin carries a premium in almost any condition. The 1928 Philadelphia and 1934-S are scarce. Most others sell a little over silver when worn.

Trade dollars

Trade dollars were struck from 1873 to 1885 for commerce in Asia. They are 90 percent silver and carry collector premiums. Copies are common, especially of the later dates, so every trade dollar we see gets weighed, measured and tested.

Certified dollars

Dollars in PCGS and NGC holders are priced on their label grade and recent sales. High-grade certified Morgans can sell for many times what a raw coin of the same date brings. We check each holder and verify its certification number.

Dollars from the bank

Until the early 1960s, Ohio banks paid out silver dollars on request, and some families made a habit of asking. When the Treasury stopped releasing them in 1964, people who had saved rolls and bags found themselves holding more than they realized. Those dollars are still in Central Ohio closets.

How the offer is laid out

Better dollars go on the offer one to a line, with date, mint mark, grade and price. Common circulated dollars are grouped. You can see at a glance where the premiums sit and sell some dollars while keeping others.

GuideDo coin buyers pay over spot?

Get a free offer

We call back the same day to set a private time.

Add a description (optional)

FAQ

Frequently asked

Are CC dollars worth more?

Usually. Carson City dollars carry collector premiums, and some dates are scarce.

Do you buy bags of dollars?

Yes. Bring the bag and we will count and sort it with you.

Are Eisenhower dollars silver?

Most are not. Some San Francisco collector versions from 1971 to 1976 are 40 percent silver.