Skip to content
Columbus Coin BuyersCoins, gold and silver

Home / What we buy / Old coins

Selling old coins in Columbus

Folders, albums, rolls and jars. We separate silver from clad, check every coin collectors might want and tell you honestly what is common.

Coin folder and magnifying glass

Coins we buy

  • Indian Head and wheat cents
  • Buffalo nickels and silver war nickels
  • Mercury and Roosevelt silver dimes
  • Standing Liberty and Washington silver quarters
  • Walking Liberty and Franklin halves
  • Barber and Seated Liberty silver
  • Proof sets and mint sets
  • Graded coins in PCGS and NGC holders

How old coins are priced

Coins struck in 90 percent silver, which means U.S. dimes, quarters and halves through 1964, are always worth at least their silver. Copper and nickel coins start at face value.

Above that floor, the date, the mint and the condition decide. We look at every candidate coin under magnification and list the better ones separately on the offer.

Coins in Columbus homes

Columbus had a lot of steady, cash-paid work for most of the last century: the rail yards, the Lazarus store downtown, the factories along the east side, state government offices. Workers who handled coins every day often pulled out the old ones, and the habit got passed down.

That is why so many Central Ohio collections are folders and jars rather than fancy cabinets. They are mostly common coins, with silver mixed in and the occasional date worth a second look.

What Central Ohio folders usually hold

The blue cardboard folders sold at every five and dime from the 1940s on were how most Ohioans collected. A typical Columbus estate has a few of them, half filled. Here is roughly how each kind sells.

  • Lincoln cent folders: mostly a few cents a coin, with a scarce date now and then
  • Jefferson nickel folders: face value or a little over, except war nickels, which hold silver
  • Roosevelt dime folders: the silver years carry silver value
  • Washington quarter folders: silver through 1964, plus a few scarce early dates
  • Walking Liberty and Franklin folders: all silver, some dates worth more

Indian Head cents

Indian Head cents were struck from 1859 to 1909. Most are common, but worn examples still sell for more than wheat cents, and a few dates are scarce: the 1877 above all, plus the 1869, 1871, 1872 and the San Francisco cents of 1908 and 1909. Full LIBERTY on the headband is a sign of a better grade.

Mercury dimes

The Winged Liberty dime, nicknamed the Mercury dime, was struck from 1916 to 1945, and every one is 90 percent silver. The 1916-D is the famous rarity, and the 1921 and 1921-D are scarce too. Collectors also pay up for coins with full split bands on the fasces on the back, a sign of a sharp strike.

Errors and oddities

Doubled dies, off-center strikes, clipped planchets and missing clad layers attract collectors. Most coins people suspect are errors turn out to be damage that happened after they left the mint. A look under magnification settles which one you have.

Large cents and early copper

Large cents, the big copper coins struck from 1793 to 1857, still turn up in old Ohio families. Ohio was frontier country when many of them circulated, and settlers carried them west along with Spanish silver. Most surviving large cents are worn and dark, but they all carry collector value, and some early dates are worth a great deal.

Please do not scrub them. Corrosion and dark color are normal on old copper, and cleaning strips what collectors want to see.

Proof sets and mint sets

Central Ohio families ordered a lot of sets from the Mint. Proof and mint sets from 1964 and earlier contain 90 percent silver coins. Clad sets from 1968 through the early 1990s usually sell near face value. Special sets, like the 1999 and later silver proof sets, carry silver. Each year and type gets its own group and price.

GuideBuffalo nickel values

Get a free offer

We call back the same day to set a private time.

Add a description (optional)

FAQ

Frequently asked

Are Buffalo nickels worth anything?

Most are worth a little, especially with worn dates. A few dates and the 1937-D three-legged variety are worth a lot more.

Do you buy coin folders?

Yes. Leave the coins in the folder and we will look at each one there.

Should I clean old coins?

No. Cleaning lowers the price. Bring them as they are.