Skip to content
Columbus Coin BuyersCoins, gold and silver

Home / What we buy / Free appraisals

Free coin and gold appraisals in Columbus

Find out what your coins, gold and silver are worth today, in writing, with no charge if you keep everything.

Coins on a tray under a loupe in Columbus

What we appraise

  • Old U.S. coins
  • Kennedy halves and silver coins
  • Silver dollars
  • Gold coins and gold jewelry
  • Sterling silver
  • Bullion
  • Old paper money
  • Whole estates

What the appraisal gives you

A written list showing each item, what it is made of, its weight or grade and our price today.

It is a purchase appraisal. Certified appraisals for insurance, estate tax or court come from a licensed appraiser, and we can point you to one.

Appraisals around Columbus

Many people book just to learn what they have. A family going through a parent's house in Bexley, a retiree downsizing from Worthington, someone curious about a single gold coin: everyone gets the same careful look.

Keep the list, talk it over and call when you are ready. If months have passed, we update the metal prices.

Grading in plain terms

Coin grades go from 1 up to 70. Most old coins sit between Good, worn flat with a readable date, and Extremely Fine, with only the high points rubbed. Uncirculated starts at 60. For some dates, an unworn coin brings many times what a worn one does.

Graded coins

Coins in PCGS or NGC slabs are priced on the label grade. Slabs from smaller services get our own look. Raw coins are graded by eye at the table.

Updating an old appraisal

If a collection was appraised years ago, bring that paperwork. Metal prices and collector prices have both changed, and we can show you how today's numbers compare.

Questions to ask any buyer

Wherever you sell, ask which spot price the buyer uses, what share of it they pay, whether testing happens in front of you and whether every item goes on paper.

How to get ready

Bring everything as it is now, in its folders, rolls and boxes. Leave the polishing cloth at home. Receipts, old appraisals and any notes the collector kept are helpful. A few coins take about fifteen minutes. A full estate can take a couple of hours.

Appraising more than coins

Bring the whole lot: coins, gold jewelry, sterling, bullion and old paper money. We price it all in one visit, so there is no need for separate trips to a coin shop, a jeweler and a gold buyer.

GuideDo coin buyers pay over spot?

Get a free offer

We call back the same day to set a private time.

Add a description (optional)

FAQ

Frequently asked

Is the appraisal free?

Yes. No fee and no pressure to sell.

Can I use it for insurance?

Insurers usually want a certified appraiser's report. Ours is a purchase appraisal.

How long does it take?

A few coins take about fifteen minutes. A big collection can take a couple of hours.