Columbus Coin Buyers
Coin buyers in Columbus, Ohio
We buy gold, silver, coins and collections from sellers across Columbus and Central Ohio. Call to talk through what you have.
By appointment, Monday through Saturday, 10am to 5pm
When it's time to sell old coins, silver or gold, you want a straight answer about what you have and a fair offer you can understand.
We are coin buyers, plain and simple. We don't run a retail counter or try to trade you into something else. We look at what you brought, explain what we see, and make an offer.
Every piece is sorted, tested and weighed where you can watch. If a coin has collector value, we tell you why. If it's priced on metal, we show you the weight and the day's spot price.
Sell your gold Gold coins, bullion and jewelry from homes across Columbus and Central Ohio, priced against the day's spot price. What we buy
We buy single coins and whole collections, plus gold and silver in almost any form. Pick a category to read more.
-
Gold coins U.S. gold before 1933, American Gold Eagles and Buffalos, Maple Leafs, Krugerrands and other world gold. Learn more -
Silver dollars Morgan, Peace, Trade and Seated Liberty dollars, from a single coin to a bank bag. Learn more -
Silver coins and Kennedy halves Dimes, quarters and halves dated 1964 or earlier, and 40 percent Kennedy halves from 1965 to 1970. Learn more -
Old and world coins Indian Head and wheat cents, Buffalo nickels, Barber and Mercury dimes, and foreign coins. Learn more -
Bullion bars and rounds Gold, silver and platinum bars, rounds and bullion coins from the U.S. and abroad. Learn more -
Gold jewelry and scrap Rings, chains, class rings, gold watches and broken pieces, priced by karat and weight. Learn more -
Inherited collections Albums, folders, rolls and boxes left in an estate, sorted and priced item by item. Learn more -
Coin appraisals Find out what a coin or collection is worth before you decide to sell anything. Learn more
How it works
Call and describe what you have. A rough count and a few dates are enough. We answer what we can on the phone and set up a time.
We sort and weigh it with you. Everything is looked at on the table in front of you. If a piece of metal needs testing, we tell you what the test is and why.
You get an offer and make the call. Collector coins are priced on what they sell for, and metal on its weight and the day's spot price. Sell, or keep everything.
Serving Columbus and Central Ohio
We work with sellers across Franklin County and out to Delaware, Newark and the towns in between. Appointments are set by phone, Monday through Saturday, 10am to 5pm.
Columbus was laid out in 1812 on the east bank of the Scioto to be Ohio's capital, and a lot of saved coin has sat in its houses for generations.
Selling a large collection or bullion?
Call ahead so we can set aside the time to go through everything with you, piece by piece.
Call now (614) 318-8920
Is it silver?
Most of what Central Ohio sellers have is U.S. silver coinage, and the date tells you most of what you need to know.
| Coin | Dates | Silver |
|---|---|---|
| Dimes, quarters and half dollars | 1964 and earlier | 90 percent |
| Kennedy half dollars | 1965 to 1970 | 40 percent |
| Kennedy half dollars | 1971 and later | None, except special collector issues |
| Dimes and quarters | 1965 and later | None, except special proof sets |
| Jefferson war nickels | 1942 to 1945, large mint mark over Monticello | 35 percent |
| Morgan and Peace dollars | 1878 to 1935 | 90 percent |
| Eisenhower dollars | Some 1971 to 1976 collector issues with the S mint mark | 40 percent |
Silver sets the floor. Better dates and strong condition can push a coin well past its metal value. Kennedy half dollar values, date by date
Before your appointment
An evaluation goes faster, and tells you more, when the coins arrive the way you found them.
- Leave the coins uncleaned. Cleaning and polishing leave fine scratches that collectors notice right away, and they lower the price.
- Keep collections the way they are. Leave coins in their albums, folders, rolls and tubes, even if the order looks random.
- Bring the packaging and paperwork. Mint boxes, certificates, grading holders and old receipts all help.
- Call ahead for a large collection. That way we can set aside enough time to go through everything.
Coin guides
Frequently asked questions
Something else on your mind? Call (614) 318-8920 and ask.
Where can I sell coins in Columbus?
You can sell them to Columbus Coin Buyers. Call 614-318-8920 to describe what you have and set a private appointment, Monday through Saturday between 10am and 5pm.
Are my Kennedy half dollars silver?
The 1964 Kennedy halves are 90 percent silver. Those dated 1965 through 1970 are 40 percent silver. Most dated 1971 and later have no silver.
How do I know what my coins are worth?
Start with the date, the mint mark and the metal. Rarity and condition decide the rest, and those are hard to judge at home. Call us and we can tell you which coins deserve a closer look.
Do coin buyers pay over spot?
For collector coins, often. Common bullion is priced against the spot price instead. Our guide explains where the line falls.
Should I clean my coins before selling?
No. Cleaning strips the original surface, and collectors pay less for cleaned coins. Bring them exactly as they are.
Do you buy inherited coin collections?
Yes, from a single coin to a full estate. Leave everything as you found it and gather any paperwork or Mint packaging. If you are an executor, we can talk through the collection with you before you decide anything.
Do I need ID to sell?
Yes. Anyone selling needs a government-issued photo ID.
Ready to sell? Give us a call.
Call and tell us what you have. We can answer most questions on the phone and set up a time to look at everything.
(614) 318-8920By appointment, Monday through Saturday, 10am to 5pm.
Request an offer
Prefer not to call? Leave your name and number and we will call you back to talk it through.