Skip to content
Columbus Coin BuyersCoins, gold and silver

Central Ohio coin and gold buyers

Sell coins, gold and silver in Columbus

From a roll of 1964 Kennedy halves to a parent's whole coin cabinet, we grade, weigh and price every piece with you and hand over the offer on paper.

  • No-cost appraisal, no obligation
  • Every gram on a scale with the display facing you
  • Same-day payment by cash or bank wire
Silver halves, quarters and dimes from before 1965
Gold $3,864.26Silver $47.53per troy ounce, today

Get a free offer

We call back the same day to set a private time.

Add a description (optional)

01 / Who we are

Plain dealing in Central Ohio

Columbus families are savers. A grandmother in Clintonville kept every Kennedy half the bank handed her. A machinist in Linden filled folders from his pay envelope for thirty years. A couple in Upper Arlington bought a gold coin every Christmas through the 1980s. When it comes time to sell, most people just want to know what they have and get a fair, clear number.

That is what an appointment with us is for. We sort the silver from the clad, check the dates collectors care about, test and weigh the gold and write a price next to every item. You decide what to do with it.

03 / Process

How a sale goes

  1. Call or use the form

    A short description is enough. We call back the same day to pick a time.

  2. Look over everything together

    Coins are checked under magnification, and gold and silver go on the scale in front of you.

  3. Make your choice

    Sell and get paid that day, or keep it all and take the written offer home.

04 / Local

A capital built on purpose

Most Ohio cities grew up around a river crossing or a canal. Columbus was laid out in 1812 on a bluff above the Scioto for one purpose: to be the state capital. German families built the brick cottages of German Village in the 1800s, the university opened in 1870, and the city grew steadily on government, insurance, retail and research jobs.

Steady paychecks and frugal habits mean Central Ohio homes hold a lot of saved coin. We see more Kennedy halves here than almost anything else, along with silver dollars, Buffalo nickels and gold coins bought as savings.

1964 and later

Kennedy half values

Which Kennedys are 90 percent silver, which are 40 percent and which are worth only face.

Read the guide →
1913 to 1938

Buffalo nickels

Most are worth a little. A few dates and the three-legged variety are worth a lot.

Read the guide →
Every sale

Do buyers pay over spot?

When a coin can sell above its metal value and when it cannot.

Read the guide →

05 / Coverage

Around Central Ohio

We work with sellers across Franklin County and out to Delaware, Newark and the towns in between.

FAQ

Frequently asked

Where can I sell coins in Columbus?

Columbus Coin Buyers buys old coins, Kennedy halves, silver dollars, gold and bullion by private appointment, Monday to Saturday. Call 614-318-8920 or send the form to set a time.

Are my Kennedy half dollars silver?

The 1964 ones are 90 percent silver. The 1965 through 1970 coins carry 40 percent. Most dated 1971 and later have no silver.

Do you pay over spot?

For collector coins, often. For plain bullion, offers are a share of spot. Our guide explains the difference.

Is there a charge to have coins looked at?

No. Looking costs you nothing, and turning the offer down costs nothing either.

How do you pay?

Smaller sales are paid in cash. For bigger amounts, the money arrives by wire before the day is out.

See what your coins and gold are worth

Book a free appraisal anywhere in Central Ohio. We check every piece with you and hand you the offer on paper.

Call (614) 318-8920Request an offer